Both/and may be the answer. Before I begin my thoughts on this for today, let me say that although I have taught two hybrid courses, I am not necessarily a fan - but I do think we need to get more in depth thinking done on this...as uncomfortable and/or unpalatable it may feel.
We are hearing more and more about online teaching these days. The need for it. The push towards it. The pros and the cons of taking this approach. Our own Dr. Shelley Steenrod has looked at differences between an online and traditional approaches to teaching a social work service learning course, for example.
The applicability of online methods for social work education SHOULD be a topic of hot debate for us. I even heard last week that there is a 100% online social work program. Yet, only once in a while, we visit- and revisit - this issue in our School of Social Work's faculty meetings. This year, one of our faculty members is teaching an online/hybrid version of one of our required MSW courses in a hybrid fashion for the first time. It is a course in the human behavior in the social environment sequence. We are anticipating an interesting discussion at the end of the semester...but I often get the feeling that we need to delve much more deeply into this topic, and really make some decisions about how to proceed with "all of this online learning stuff." I think we are behind the curve that is curving on without our input. I heard this when our Dean visited us recently...so, let's think about this more, and make some of the future with our own imprint - whether it is a full-embrace of online learning or not - or somewhere in between (my bet).
Given all of this stuff on my brain's back burner, I was interested to see the results of a recent survey of faculty from around the country re: online learning. Check out these interesting data on faculty views about online learning from around the country...whether you "agree" with online learning or not, still interesting. These charts are derived from a survey of 10,720 faculty members at 69 colleges and universities. I was particularly interested to note that 82% of faculty who had NOT taught an online (or hybrid?) course indicated that they thought this medium was an inferior way to teach as compared to traditional face-to-face teaching. I was not surprised to see that most survey participants felt that preparing an online course required A LOT more work than a traditional course...this has certainly been my experience - and I know I would have been "in the weeds" without some training from SSU's Center for Teaching and Learning. Perhaps most interesting - and compelling - was the fact that 82% of survey participants indicated that their motivation for adopting this teaching approach was to "meet student needs for flexible access." Boy, this sure sounds like SSU to me.
Given my own limited experience with hybrid teaching (part online, part in-person), here are my thoughts on the questions that should guide our discussions:
1) What do we need to change about how WE TEACH and WE ENGAGE STUDENTS in order to feel ok about exploring any positives of online teaching approaches?
2) Which social work courses are most appropriate for online teaching?
3) What do our students think about their online courses?
4) Given the difference in workload re: preparing to teach an online course vs. a traditional, face-to-face course, what incentives are in place to entice/encourage us?
So, once again, as someone that is somewhat in the negative camp on all of this - let's really start to talk about this issue and make the dialogue our own.
Saturday, January 15, 2011
Saturday, January 8, 2011
Time to do some thinking about you, your students - and Facebook...
Social media is ever-present in the news these days - not to mention ever-present in many of our lives. I joined the Facebook wagon late - but have enjoyed re-connecting with high school and college friends. Facebook has also been a great family photo sharing spot. However, I have always felt a bit strange when students ask to "friend" me. "To friend," in case you are unaware, is a verb indicating that one has asked another to become "friends" on Facebook (or MySpace, or.... etc.). After ignoring my Facebook "friend request" page for many months in a true avoidance of the issue...I decided that my policy would be that I would do the following:
a) Never accept a "friend" request from a current or potential future student
b) Never request to "friend" a current, potential future or former student
c) Would accept "friends" who were graduated students with whom I had some significant and positive teacher-student interaction
With respect to a) and b), I don't want my students to see my photos of family gatherings or my somewhat wacky running commentary on my favorite FoodNetwork show "Chopped." Or, for that matter, photos of my new home. It isn't too long ago that a local professor who had proffered a low grade opened her door to an irate and aggressive student. I may be paranoid here, but still, better safe than sorry. This takes some of the fun off of a post about Facebook, I do realize that.
With respect c), I am always shocked when students who have failed out of my courses or who have been called on the carpet re: plagiarism show up in my "friend request" page.
So, imagine my surprise, when logging on to Facebook, I saw that a friend from college (Jackie Cohen, who works as an Editor for Allfacebook.com, which should tell us something about our need to be thinking about the Facebook phenomenon) posted this article on Virginia's potential ban on Facebook friendships between students and teachers - albeit not at the undergraduate or graduate level - but still something to consider. Although this move appears to relate to sexual relationships between teachers and students, I still think it is a good discussion point. The article also references, for example, the fact that students and teachers in some cases communicate via text message. So, I have posted the story in below...but would love to hear your thoughts on how Schools of Social Work should handle both the issue of Facebook and perhaps texting?
Please share this blog posting with your social work academic colleagues - the blog is located at http://socialworktechnotes.blogspot.com/ and this will be the first posting (or in a few days, the second, and can be found in the blog archive if scrolling down does not work).
School teachers may be officially discouraged, if not completely banned, from communicating with students via Facebook, depending on the outcome of a January 13 vote by the Virginia Department of Education.
The state educational agency may set an example for others in the U.S. in requiring teachers to deny or ignore friend requests from students.
This would comply with a report called “Guidelines for the Prevention of Sexual Misconduct and Abuse in Virginia Public Schools.”
The big picture: The Virginia Department of Education has dealt with of 120 cases of sexual misconduct between teachers and minors since 2000, according to The Daily Caller.
The Board’s proposal for reining in potential misconduct would prohibit teachers from sending text messages to students one-on-one and also disallow private communications via noprofessional social networking sites.
If a student sends a friend request to a Virginia public school employee via Facebook, not only would that recipient have to decline or disregard it, but also would have to report it to a direct supervisor. This would have to go in writing on the next business day and include the date, time and nature of the contact.
This is all still in the suggestion stage, as a spokesperson for the Virginia Department of Education told The Daily Caller that she couldn’t “begin to speculate on how the board will vote.” If approved, then Virginia schools would be encouraged to adopt the policy.
This sounds like the kind of measure that parents would support in the interest of protecting their children. School officials probably like this too because of the cost of potential lawsuits related to anything resembling “sexual misconduct.” But I suspect students might have mixed reactions to this proposal, and free speech poponents might actively dislike the idea.
What’s your opinion on whether school employees should be able to communicate with students one-on-one via social networks and text messages? Do employers have the right to dictate how staff use Facebook even during off hours?
a) Never accept a "friend" request from a current or potential future student
b) Never request to "friend" a current, potential future or former student
c) Would accept "friends" who were graduated students with whom I had some significant and positive teacher-student interaction
With respect to a) and b), I don't want my students to see my photos of family gatherings or my somewhat wacky running commentary on my favorite FoodNetwork show "Chopped." Or, for that matter, photos of my new home. It isn't too long ago that a local professor who had proffered a low grade opened her door to an irate and aggressive student. I may be paranoid here, but still, better safe than sorry. This takes some of the fun off of a post about Facebook, I do realize that.
With respect c), I am always shocked when students who have failed out of my courses or who have been called on the carpet re: plagiarism show up in my "friend request" page.
So, imagine my surprise, when logging on to Facebook, I saw that a friend from college (Jackie Cohen, who works as an Editor for Allfacebook.com, which should tell us something about our need to be thinking about the Facebook phenomenon) posted this article on Virginia's potential ban on Facebook friendships between students and teachers - albeit not at the undergraduate or graduate level - but still something to consider. Although this move appears to relate to sexual relationships between teachers and students, I still think it is a good discussion point. The article also references, for example, the fact that students and teachers in some cases communicate via text message. So, I have posted the story in below...but would love to hear your thoughts on how Schools of Social Work should handle both the issue of Facebook and perhaps texting?
Please share this blog posting with your social work academic colleagues - the blog is located at http://socialworktechnotes.blogspot.com/ and this will be the first posting (or in a few days, the second, and can be found in the blog archive if scrolling down does not work).
-----------
Virginia May Ban Teachers From Facebooking With Students
Posted by Jackie Cohen on January 7th, 2011 7:44 PM
School teachers may be officially discouraged, if not completely banned, from communicating with students via Facebook, depending on the outcome of a January 13 vote by the Virginia Department of Education.
The state educational agency may set an example for others in the U.S. in requiring teachers to deny or ignore friend requests from students.
This would comply with a report called “Guidelines for the Prevention of Sexual Misconduct and Abuse in Virginia Public Schools.”
The big picture: The Virginia Department of Education has dealt with of 120 cases of sexual misconduct between teachers and minors since 2000, according to The Daily Caller.
The Board’s proposal for reining in potential misconduct would prohibit teachers from sending text messages to students one-on-one and also disallow private communications via noprofessional social networking sites.
If a student sends a friend request to a Virginia public school employee via Facebook, not only would that recipient have to decline or disregard it, but also would have to report it to a direct supervisor. This would have to go in writing on the next business day and include the date, time and nature of the contact.
This is all still in the suggestion stage, as a spokesperson for the Virginia Department of Education told The Daily Caller that she couldn’t “begin to speculate on how the board will vote.” If approved, then Virginia schools would be encouraged to adopt the policy.
This sounds like the kind of measure that parents would support in the interest of protecting their children. School officials probably like this too because of the cost of potential lawsuits related to anything resembling “sexual misconduct.” But I suspect students might have mixed reactions to this proposal, and free speech poponents might actively dislike the idea.
What’s your opinion on whether school employees should be able to communicate with students one-on-one via social networks and text messages? Do employers have the right to dictate how staff use Facebook even during off hours?
-----------
Tuesday, January 4, 2011
On leaky pens, lost papers and smartphones for academics
I do have a smartphone - and I often wonder if I am using it as well as I might....but somehow, figuring out how to do so feels as though it would take a lot of time that I don't have, especially in the syllabus and WebCT preparation crunch phase that is right now, before the semester starts. So, imagine my surprise when upon procrastinating, I found this article in The Chronicle (yes, my usual go-to source for techie info for social work academics) that addresses this topic...see what you think, and may it be inspiring and/or useful to you...I am particularly interested in the attendance "app" or application....but cannot imagine reading much on the screen of my smartphone - my middle-aged eyes cannot handle that.
While I do not decry the good old pencil or pen, I do think we have some good options to consider here...
Not long ago, it seemed absurd for academics to carry around a computer, camera, and GPS device everywhere they went. Actually, it still seems absurd. But many professors (and administrators) now do just that in the form of all-in-one devices. Smartphones or tablet computers combine many functions in a hand-held gadget, and some users are discovering clever ways to teach and do research with the ubiquitous machines.
For many on campus, checking e-mail on the go is the first killer app of the hand-held world. The downside: Having that ability can mean working more than ever—answering student e-mails while in line at the grocery store, responding to a journal editor during lunch. There can be benefits, though. Some professors say they find that carrying the Internet in their pocket helps them collaborate, teach, and collect data in new ways that include e-mail but go far beyond it.
A handful of colleges are running expensive pilot projects in which they give out iPhones or iPads to students and professors to see what happens when everyone goes mobile.
Some of the most innovative applications for hand-held devices, however, have come from professors working on their own. They find ways to adapt popular smartphone software to the classroom setting, or even write their own code.
That's what I discovered when I put out a call on Twitter, as well as to a major e-mail list of college public-relations officers, asking about the areas in which professors and college officials are making the most of their mobile devices. Here are the six scenarios that people mentioned most often. I have highlighted the apps in each category that got users' highest marks.
He couldn't find any software to keep those paper check marks on a smartphone, so he wrote his own app about two years ago, in a two-week burst of coding. He called his task-specific app Attendance and put it on the iTunes store for other professors, charging a couple of bucks (and adding features as colleagues suggested them). So far he has earned about $20,000 from the more than 7,500 people who have virtually shouted "Here."
Several professors said their favorite feature of the app (which now sells for $4.99) is a flashcard function that helps them learn the names of their students. It literally puts names to faces, if professors add photos supplied by the college. Some professors take pictures of their students on the first day of class and put them in the app. An iPad version takes advantage of the larger screen of Apple's tablet computer.
That's just one of many research projects adding smartphone interfaces to so-called "crowd science," in which the public is invited to add structured data to an online database. "For crowd science, I think it's definitely the next step," Mr. Shilling told me, although he says he prefers logging roadkill with pen and paper, which he thinks encourages more colorful write-ups than an app. "My kids tell me that I'm a Neanderthal," he jokes.
Other options for building a personal virtual library are GoodReader and Evernote, both of which allow readers to highlight and take notes on any PDF saved to the system. Students, too, say they find the services useful. Shep McAllister, a junior at Trinity University, in Texas, who writes for the HackCollegeStudent blog about students' use of technology, said he turns to the iPad version of GoodReader for much of his assigned reading, because his university's electronic reserve offers documents in PDF, so he can easily transfer them to the service. "It's like you're holding the actual page in front of you," he told me.
Mr. McAllister, the student blogger at Trinity, uses his iPhone's camera as a document scanner, with an app called JotNot Pro. After he takes a picture of a page of text, the app (which costs 99 cents), can turn it into a PDF file for easy review later. "If I get a handout from a professor, I'm always afraid I'm going to lose it," he said, noting that he tries to scan any class-related documents with his phone.
Textbook publishers see the iPad and other tablets as a better medium to one day replace printed textbooks completely. A company named Inkling creates textbooks made for iPads, with interactive features and videos—things that paper volumes cannot do.
For professors who shift to the app world, there's one gadget they can do without: that messy ballpoint pen.
While I do not decry the good old pencil or pen, I do think we have some good options to consider here...
6 Top Smartphone Apps to Improve Teaching, Research, and Your Life
Academics describe going mobile to plan lectures, keep up with scholarship, and run classes
By Jeffrey R. Young
Not long ago, it seemed absurd for academics to carry around a computer, camera, and GPS device everywhere they went. Actually, it still seems absurd. But many professors (and administrators) now do just that in the form of all-in-one devices. Smartphones or tablet computers combine many functions in a hand-held gadget, and some users are discovering clever ways to teach and do research with the ubiquitous machines.
For many on campus, checking e-mail on the go is the first killer app of the hand-held world. The downside: Having that ability can mean working more than ever—answering student e-mails while in line at the grocery store, responding to a journal editor during lunch. There can be benefits, though. Some professors say they find that carrying the Internet in their pocket helps them collaborate, teach, and collect data in new ways that include e-mail but go far beyond it.
A handful of colleges are running expensive pilot projects in which they give out iPhones or iPads to students and professors to see what happens when everyone goes mobile.
Some of the most innovative applications for hand-held devices, however, have come from professors working on their own. They find ways to adapt popular smartphone software to the classroom setting, or even write their own code.
That's what I discovered when I put out a call on Twitter, as well as to a major e-mail list of college public-relations officers, asking about the areas in which professors and college officials are making the most of their mobile devices. Here are the six scenarios that people mentioned most often. I have highlighted the apps in each category that got users' highest marks.
Taking Attendance
Calling roll may not seem like an activity that needs an upgrade. But David M. Reed, a professor of computer science at Capital University, in Ohio, saw his iPhone as a way to streamline the process and keep a digital backup. "I used to use a piece of paper," he said. "What would happen is invariably I would lose that piece of paper halfway through the semester."He couldn't find any software to keep those paper check marks on a smartphone, so he wrote his own app about two years ago, in a two-week burst of coding. He called his task-specific app Attendance and put it on the iTunes store for other professors, charging a couple of bucks (and adding features as colleagues suggested them). So far he has earned about $20,000 from the more than 7,500 people who have virtually shouted "Here."
Several professors said their favorite feature of the app (which now sells for $4.99) is a flashcard function that helps them learn the names of their students. It literally puts names to faces, if professors add photos supplied by the college. Some professors take pictures of their students on the first day of class and put them in the app. An iPad version takes advantage of the larger screen of Apple's tablet computer.
Collecting Data
A professor at the University of California at Davis is asking drivers to help him with his research on roadkill by logging any dead squirrel, possum, or other critter they see along the highway. At first he asked people to write down the location and details about the carcass on a scrap of paper and upload the information to a Web site when they got home. Then the research team built an iPhone app to let citizen-scientists participate at the scene. It's more convenient, and it gives the researchers better data, because a phone's GPS feature can send along exact location coordinates (and the app encourages users to take a picture with the phone's camera). The lead researcher at Davis, Fraser Shilling, in the department of environmental science and policy, said the app should hit the iTunes store any day now, though he and his colleagues haven't decided whether the name will be WildlifeObs or simply Roadkill.That's just one of many research projects adding smartphone interfaces to so-called "crowd science," in which the public is invited to add structured data to an online database. "For crowd science, I think it's definitely the next step," Mr. Shilling told me, although he says he prefers logging roadkill with pen and paper, which he thinks encourages more colorful write-ups than an app. "My kids tell me that I'm a Neanderthal," he jokes.
Reading Scholarly Articles
Instead of clicking print when saving an article for later reading, many professors now send the document to their phone or tablet computer. Those I talked with cited a range of apps designed for the task, though Dropbox was cited most frequently. The commercial app is available for iPhones, iPads, and for smartphones or tablets running Google's Android operating system. David Parry, an assistant professor of emergent media and communications at the University of Texas at Dallas, said he uses Dropbox for both scholarly reading and keeping track of documents for the courses he teaches. "The key for me is I store all my syllabuses there," he told me. "Anytime someone has a question about a syllabus, I have it—anywhere." So when a student e-mails to ask about an assignment deadline while Mr. Parry is at the grocery store, he knows.Other options for building a personal virtual library are GoodReader and Evernote, both of which allow readers to highlight and take notes on any PDF saved to the system. Students, too, say they find the services useful. Shep McAllister, a junior at Trinity University, in Texas, who writes for the HackCollegeStudent blog about students' use of technology, said he turns to the iPad version of GoodReader for much of his assigned reading, because his university's electronic reserve offers documents in PDF, so he can easily transfer them to the service. "It's like you're holding the actual page in front of you," he told me.
Recording Notes
Just having a camera on hand can sometimes help in the classroom. Aaron Delwiche, an associate professor of communication at Trinity, often uses the camera built into his Android phone to snap a picture of his whiteboard before he erases it. When he breaks the class into groups for a project, the photos remind him who was on each team and what they came up with. High-end whiteboards offer a function to print out or e-mail their contents, but some professors say their phone cameras do just as well.Mr. McAllister, the student blogger at Trinity, uses his iPhone's camera as a document scanner, with an app called JotNot Pro. After he takes a picture of a page of text, the app (which costs 99 cents), can turn it into a PDF file for easy review later. "If I get a handout from a professor, I'm always afraid I'm going to lose it," he said, noting that he tries to scan any class-related documents with his phone.
Using Textbook Tools
Cellphone screens are tiny compared with textbook pages, but several publishers now offer apps to read their e-textbooks on mobile devices. CourseSmart, a company that sells electronic versions of textbooks from major publishers, offers a free iPhone app to read books purchased through its service. It may not be ideal for long reading sessions, but it could be a handy way for professors to look over the material to remember what their students are reading.Textbook publishers see the iPad and other tablets as a better medium to one day replace printed textbooks completely. A company named Inkling creates textbooks made for iPads, with interactive features and videos—things that paper volumes cannot do.
Planning Lectures
Brainstorming for classroom talks has gone high-tech with "mind mapping" software that encourages arranging thoughts and ideas in nonlinear diagrams. These programs have been available for years on laptops and desktop computers, but some professors say the touch-screen interface of smartphones or tablet computers enhances the process, letting scholars toss around ideas with a flick of the finger. Gerald C. Gannod, director of mobile learning at Miami University, in Ohio, recommends Thinking Space for Android devices, MindBlowing for the iPhone, and Popplet for the iPad. Mr. Delwiche, of Trinity University, likes MindJet. "It's great when organizing papers or project ideas," he said.For professors who shift to the app world, there's one gadget they can do without: that messy ballpoint pen.
Sunday, January 2, 2011
On keeping up with the journals - via the Internet - for you or your students
Keeping up to date on the current knowledge in social work journals - and in our specific topic areas is, of course, a challenge. I just came across this posting from last year - but it is a great guide that you - or your students - can use in order to stay up-to-date...may it be useful to you in the new year!
The following is a list of the top social work journals from the Child Welfare League of America (permalink is here with both impact factor and eigen factor information)

Keeping Up With Journals
[This is a guest post by Lincoln Mullen, a Ph.D. student in American history at Brandeis University.]
If you’re an academic, you have to read lots of journals to keep up with the research in your field. You’ve probably learned how to search JSTOR or other academic databases to find articles and book reviews in back issues. But keeping up with the most recent issues is a different matter. You’ll have to find the most recent issue online and sign up for reminders when new issues are published, which I’ll describe how to do in this post.



The following is a list of the top social work journals from the Child Welfare League of America (permalink is here with both impact factor and eigen factor information)
Keeping Up With Journals
[This is a guest post by Lincoln Mullen, a Ph.D. student in American history at Brandeis University.]
If you’re an academic, you have to read lots of journals to keep up with the research in your field. You’ve probably learned how to search JSTOR or other academic databases to find articles and book reviews in back issues. But keeping up with the most recent issues is a different matter. You’ll have to find the most recent issue online and sign up for reminders when new issues are published, which I’ll describe how to do in this post.
You can start by making a list of the journals you want to read. I’m a grad student in history, so I’ll use the American Historical Review, the William and Mary Quarterly, and the Journal of the Early Republic as examples.
Once you have a list of journals, you should figure out where you can get access to them. I’ll deal first with getting access online, then briefly discuss reading journals in print.
Finding recent journals online
One way that you might have access to journals online is by subscribing to the print edition or being a member of a professional organization. For example, if you’re a member of the American Historical Association, then you can login to the AHR from the AHA website.
Your academic library is almost certainly the best source for online versions of journals. Libraries vary widely in the number of journals that they subscribe to, so your library may have every journal you could wish for, or it may have very few. If your academic library doesn’t have everything you need, try looking at a large public library in your state, such as the Boston Public Library or the New York Public Library.
Many libraries have a database where you can search by journal title to see which databases hold which issues of a journal. For example, if I search the database at my institution for the AHR, I get the following results.
You can see that there are several databases that have back issues of the AHR, but that I can get the most recent issue only from the University of Chicago Press. I ran similar searches for two other journals, and found that I can get the most recent issues of the WMQ from History Cooperative and of the JER from the EBSCO databases or from Project Muse. If I click the links to any of those databases, I can navigate to the issue I want.
Alerts for new issues online
Finding the most recent issues is one thing, but it would be nice to receive an alert when an issue is released online. Most databases provide a way to subscribe to alerts via e-mail or RSS. In general, I prefer e-mail, because sometimes RSS readers don’t work through library proxies, but your mileage may vary.
For the AHR, there are links in the left sidebar to subscribe via e-mail or RSS. You can paste the link to the RSS feed into your favorite feed reader. If you choose to subscribe to the e-mail, you’ll have to register with the site. The signup process is far from convenient, but you should only have to do it once.
Though the most recent issue of the WMQ is available from History Cooperative, that website does not offer a way to subscribe to alerts. For that journal, your best option is probably to subscribe to H-OIEAHC, an e-mail list sponsored by the same institution that publishes the WMQ.
The JER has its most recent issue in two databases, both of which offer alerts. At the Project Muse page for the journal, the right sidebar offers RSS and e-mail options. Subscribing via e-mail at Project Muse is very simple.
Signing up for alerts to the JER from one of the EBSCO databases, such as Academic Search Premier, can be complex. From the journal page, you’ll have to click “alerts” then either subscribe to the RSS feed or register for an account and sign in to get an e-mail alert.
If you can’t figure out how to sign up for alerts, or even where you can find journals online, consider asking for help at your library’s reference desk or help desk. Most library workers are glad to teach people how to use the library resources. (I should know; I was one.)
Subscribing to e-mail alerts or RSS feeds for the key journals in your field can help you keep up with your journal reading. Sometimes, though, a low-tech solution is best. If you’re a member of a professional association like the AHA or SHEAR, you’re probably getting a print version of its journal delivered to your home or office. For me, at least, there is nothing like the physical presence of a journal or book to remind me to read it. (As a bonus, you can be glad that your subscription supports the publication of the journal.) Even for journals that you don’t subscribe to, your academic library is probably receiving a print copy. By scheduling half a day every month or two to plow through the journals you subscribe to or the ones available at your library, you can stay caught up on your journal reading.
Whatever works for you–that’s the ProfHacker way.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


